Lawyers for Donziger File Evidence Showing Chevron’s Star Witness Lied On the Stand During Company’s RICO Case


Lawyers for Donziger File Evidence Showing Chevron’s Star Witness Lied On the Stand During Company’s RICO Case


NEW YORK, Nov. 05 /CSRwire/ – Lawyers representing U.S. attorney Steven Donziger today filed sworn testimony showing Chevron’s star witness Alberto Guerra admitted accepting large cash payments from the company and lying on the stand to protect the oil giant from paying a $9.5 billion environmental judgment owed to villagers in Ecuador’s rainforest.

“This is an extraordinary case, and these are extraordinary developments,” said the filing, made by Deepak Gupta, Donziger’s lead attorney.  “They not only bear on the legal issues in this appeal, they also exonerate Steven Donziger of the allegations of wrongdoing that Chevron has levied against him.”

The filing, available here, asserts that “new developments cast grave doubt on the truth of [Chevron’s] fraud allegations and confirm Chevron’s extensive pollution of the rainforest.

“These developments heighten the likelihood of inconsistent results and illustrate why this proceeding is both unnecessary and in contravention of basic norms of international comity,” said the motion, made to a three-judge panel hearing an appeal of Chevron’s civil racketeering case filed in the United States against Donziger, Ecuadorian lawyer Pablo Fajardo, and the 47 named plaintiffs who first pressed their class-action environmental claims against Chevron in 1993.

The Ecuadorian villagers, who suffer from high cancer rates and are often forced to consume contaminated water in areas where Chevron operated in Ecuador, won a stunning judgment against the American company in 2011 that has since been affirmed unanimously by Ecuador’s Supreme Court. (Here is a summary of the overwhelming evidence against Chevron in Ecuador.)

The filing by Gupta, made to the United States Court of Appeal for the Second Circuit, makes the following points:

  • Guerra admitted in a separate arbitral proceeding between Chevron and Ecuador’s government that he accepted roughly $2 million in cash and benefits from Chevron to testify for the company and that he only had $146 in his bank account when he struck his deal to get paid.
  • Guerra admitted in the arbitration that he lied on the witness stand in New York during the racketeering case about key elements of Chevron’s “bribe” allegation, which Donziger has categorically rejected.
  • Guerra admitted during the arbitration that the key corroborating evidence relied on by Judge Lewis A. Kaplan to credit his testimony – shipping records from an Ecuadorian airline – had nothing to do with the Chevron pollution case, contrary to his testimony in Kaplan’s court.
  • Guerra also admitted that he repeatedly “exaggerated” his knowledge of the case to obtain more money from Chevron and that he knew Chevron would not pay unless he came up with a story to implicate the trial judge in a bribery scheme.
  • Guerra also conceded in his arbitral testimony that there is no credible evidence corroborating his allegation that the lawyers for the Ecuadorians ghostwrote the trial court judgment.

Chevron brought its RICO case in the U.S. the same month that an Ecuador trial court found the company guilty of deliberately dumping billions of gallons of toxic oil waste into rivers and streams in Ecuador relied on by thousands of local inhabitants for their drinking water.  Virtually all of the Ecuadorian plaintiffs rejected the jurisdiction of U.S. judge Lewis A. Kaplan, who refused to seat a jury and failed to disclose he had investments in Chevron when he was presiding over the case.

Kaplan also refused to hear the scientific evidence of Chevron’s environmental contamination relied on by the courts in Ecuador to find the company liable, prompting Donziger to call the proceeding a “show trial”.   “Chevron made a mockery of justice in Kaplan’s courtroom, and they did it with the active cooperation of Kaplan himself,” Donziger said at the time.  (For background on the numerous problems with the RICO case, see here.)

In ruling in favor of Chevron in the racketeering case, Kaplan had credited Guerra’s testimony that the plaintiffs bribed the trial judge based on information now proven to be false and that Guerra admits he lied about, according to the latest filing.

Luis Yanza, a longtime leader of the affected communities in Ecuador, blasted the oil company for its abusive litigation tactics and its refusal to comply with the court order that it clean up its contamination.  Chevron has used at least 60 law firms and 2,000 lawyers to try to beat back the villagers, who are currently enforcing the Ecuadorian judgment against Chevron’s assets in Canada and Brazil.

“Let us be clear: Chevron’s attacks against Steven Donziger, Pablo Fajardo and other advocates of the very communities it poisoned in Ecuador must cease immediately,” said Yanza, who won the prestigious Goldman Environmental Prize.   “We consider an attack against any one of our advocates to be an attack against all, including the thousands of innocent people suffering death and grave harm because of Chevron’s reckless misconduct and criminal fraud in Ecuador.”

Kaplan already was reversed once in the racketeering case when he took the unprecedented stop of trying – from his Manhattan courtroom — to block enforcement of the Ecuador judgment in any country in the world.

Kaplan’s racketeering decision in favor of Chevron has little practical effect, as the villagers are enforcing their judgment in countries where Kaplan has no jurisdiction, said Yanza.  The Canada Supreme Court recently ruled in a unanimous opinion that the villagers could attempt to seize Chevron’s assets in that country, which are estimated to have $15 billion in value.

After the transcripts of Guerra’s arbitral testimony first became available publicly last week, Donziger issued the following statement:

“The disclosure of Guerra’s corrupt witness testimony is just the latest of many examples of how Chevron has engaged in gross misconduct to sabotage legal proceedings in Ecuador and the United States to evade accountability for the deliberate dumping of billions of gallons of toxic waste.  Chevron has now been caught yet again in presenting false evidence designed to delay its court-mandated environmental clean-up in Ecuador of oil contamination that has decimated indigenous groups and caused a humanitarian catastrophe. The latest testimony from Guerra demonstrates once and for all that Chevron’s so-called racketeering case has fallen apart.   Guerra was the linchpin of Chevron’s RICO case and he now stands as an admitted liar and shocking symbol of how Chevron’s management has lost its way on the Ecuador issue. 

Guerra’s false testimony is one of many documented frauds Chevron has committed in Ecuador and elsewhere. These include the use of a sampling and analysis plan designed to hide contamination from the court, the secret videotaping of a sitting judge to try to entrap him in a fake bribery scheme, and attempts by Chevron operatives to bribe the trial judge who authored the opinion against the company.  Chevron and its lawyers also paid $2 million to Guerra for his testimony in violation of federal law and ethical rules. The company enlisted the U.S. government under false pretenses to provide Guerra and his family with political asylum.  Two Chevron lawyers – Randy Mastro and Avi Weitzman — coached Guerra for 53 consecutive days as part of a desperate effort to fictionalize a story and frame the company’s adversaries with false evidence.  

Given the latest critical developments relating to Guerra’s testimony, we reiterate our call to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals to dismiss Judge Kaplan’s “findings” of fact and legal rulings which are based largely on demonstrably false or distorted evidence already rejected unanimously by two different appellate courts in Chevron’s preferred forum of Ecuador.  Judge Kaplan’s unprecedented decision and Chevron’s illegal tactics are an affront to Ecuador’s sovereignty and reflect poorly on the American federal judiciary in the eyes of the world. “

Source: CRS News

El Telégrafo: Testigo ‘estrella’ de Chevron confiesa que mintió en litigio por contaminación
El portal informativo Vice News publicó una nota en la que se confirma que el exjuez ecuatoriano Alberto Guerra, considerado como el ‘Testigo estrella’ de Chevron en el litigio que lleva en la justicia con los amazónicos ecuatorianos por contaminación, admitió, ante un tribunal internacional, que no existe evidencia para corroborar las denuncias de supuesto soborno al juez que dictó la sentencia en contra de la petrolera.

Además, Guerra aseguró que sus testimonios juramentados fueron exagerados y, en otros casos, simplemente no fueron verdad.

El portal Ecuadorinmediato publicó la traducción de la nota:

En marzo del año pasado, el gigante petrolero, con sede en California, Chevron elogió una victoria arrolladora en una de las largas batallas legales de dos décadas en la Amazonía ecuatoriana. Un juez federal de Nueva York, Lewis Kaplan, dictaminó que los $9.500’000,000 del juicio de Lago Agrio, dirigida contra la empresa por el máximo tribunal de Ecuador, se obtuvo por medio del fraude y la coacción.


En su decisión, sobre la base de violaciones de la Ley RICO, el juez consideró que el abogado de los demandantes, Steven Donziger, cometió fraude, coerción, y pagó sobornos para ganar el juicio contra Texaco, actualmente Chevron, en 2001.

El caso colgado en gran medida del ‘testigo estrella’ de Chevron, Alberto Guerra, exjuez ecuatoriano, que ha admitido recibir grandes cantidades de dinero y otros beneficios por cooperar con Chevron. En Nueva York, Guerra declaró que había llegado a un acuerdo entre los demandantes y el juez presidente, Nicolás Zambrano: Guerra sería el escritor fantasma del veredicto, Zambrano lo firmaría, y los dos compartirían un presunto soborno de $ 500.000 de los demandantes.

En el fallo del caso RICO, el juez Kaplan declaró que la “evidencia lleva a una conclusión: Guerra dijo la verdad en relación con el soborno y el hecho esencial acerca de quién escribió la Sentencia”.

Se retracta
Pero en un testimonio dado ante el tribunal internacional, publicado ayer por el Gobierno ecuatoriano y proporcionado a Vice Noticias de antemano, Guerra ha admitido que no hay evidencia para corroborar las denuncias de un soborno o un escritor fantasma, y que gran parte de su testimonio jurado, utilizado por Kaplan en el caso RICO para bloquear la ejecución de la sentencia contra Chevron, fue exagerado y, en otros casos, simplemente no se ajusta a la verdad.

Para aquellos que han seguido el caso de cerca, incluyendo el grupo ambientalista Amazon Watch, las admisiones de Guerra podrían ascender a un “final de juego” para Chevron, cuyo testigo estrella ha admitido haber mentido bajo juramento y que ha aportado ninguna prueba de las acusaciones de que Chevron utiliza para desacreditar el gobernante ecuatoriano.

“Este es el hundimiento del Titanic del caso RICO de Chevron”, dijo Paul Paz y Miño, un portavoz del grupo de vigilancia. “Guerra no era creíble desde el primer día, y ahora ha admitido bajo juramento que él mintió sobre todo el caso y los principales cargos en el caso, de un soborno y de un veredicto de un escritor fantasma, ahora han sido probados por el mismo testigo que llevaron y les expone a es una mentira “.

Amenazan con demandar
Steven Donziger y su equipo legal han negado repetidamente las acusaciones en el caso de Lago Agrio, y han amenazado con una demanda de represalia en contra de Chevron por fraude y obstrucción de la justicia. Las admisiones de Guerra han actuado, según Donziger, como una prueba más de que Chevron está dispuesto a participar en una conducta criminal para “sabotear los procedimientos legales en Ecuador y Estados Unidos” que pretenden responsabilizar a la empresa.

“Chevron ha sido arrestado por el testimonio mentira de su principal testigo”, dijo Donziger, en respuesta a las transcripciones liberadas del tribunal internacional. “La última versión del testimonio de Guerra demuestra claramente que Chevron pagó a sus testigos estrellas enormes sumas de dinero para presentar pruebas falsas”

Source: El Telégrafo


Editorial Committee

David Dunham

Arno Ambrosius

Gustavo López Ospina

Mariana Almeida

Pieter Jan Brouwer

Assistant: Emilia Romero

SELVA Vida Sin Fronteras acknowledges Kevin Schafer’s important contribution towards protecting the highly endangered Amazon pink fresh water dolphin. Title photographs of our “The Amazon Pink Dolphin’s Voice” were taken by Mr. Schafer. 


~ by Mariana Almeida on 26 November, 2015.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: